Thursday, October 22, 2026
Debates are Dead. Long Live Debates
It's October in Ohio. Eight or ten years ago we would have been embroiled in political debates here in Cleveland. In 2018, the City Club hosted debates for candidates for US Senate, Ohio Governor, Ohio Attorney General, Congress, and Cuyahoga County Executive. And there were undoubtedly countless more across the state.
In 2018 we still thought of Ohio as a swing state, although one that had swung decidedly rightward. Debates were still an expectation of candidates and campaigns, and along with partners in the media, we were honored to be able to provide a platform for those debates with fair, deeply informed, and well prepared moderators asking meaningful questions of candidates. They were the ultimate high stakes job interviews, and it often seemed as though a powerful performance or a poor choice could have the power to determine the electoral outcome. Ohioans and operatives still remembered John Glenn's evisceration of Howard Metzenbaum in a primary debate on the City Club stage, or State Senator Michael R. White's emergence as frontrunner after a Mayoral primary debate in 1989.
Today, not so much.
You could feel it shifting in recent years. Even as we worked to create the Ohio Debate Commission as a statewide collaboration among media and civic institutions, campaigns and candidates found they could more efficiently aggregate votes through social media and surgically targeted ads. They dropped strategies to connect with persuadable voters and doubled down on activating their bases, often by inspiring fear and demonizing their opponents. There are still messages of hope and optimism, but they're vanishingly rare.
In past years, I would spend a lot of August and September working the phones, calling campaign managers and pitching the importance of debates. I've all but given up. This year, I reached out to the senate and gubernatorial campaigns once with a simple message: If you want a debate, we'll host it, and it will be fair and we will do everything we can to distribute across the state; and if you don't want a debate, we'll give you an opportunity to speak at our forum so you can connect directly with voters. The response? Crickets. And lest you think your preferred candidate actually wants a debate, allow me to be clear. Neither side is interested. Not in a debate and not in connecting with ordinary persuadable voters in a public forum that the campaigns don't control.
Despite this, I'm optimistic (or at least not hopelessly pessimistic) about our politics. Things change and evolve, and our politics in this country tend to move in cycles--individualism and the public good, corruption and good government, civic stability and civil disobedience. We happen to be in a moment that favors maximalist stances and targeted political strategy enabled by social media and the other trappings of our digital lives. It won't always be this way. There's a future we can choose that builds on how much we value face to face engagement, and how much we enjoy conversation about ideas, with real argumentation and persuasion.
The only way to find that future is by creating it. While we put up with the present and all its incentives against real engagement, we can seek opportunities to break out of our algorithmic echo chambers. We can invite one another to conversations we know will be challenging. And we can remind candidates that we would actually really like to see them on a debate stage or engaging with voters who haven’t been handpicked.
We can get to this future. We might just have put up with the present for a little while longer.
This essay was also published by Crain's Cleveland Business on Oct. 8, 2026.




